«ВРНС И РПЦ ЗАКРЫВАЮТ ТЕМУ ВОЗМОЖН... "/>

Александр Буренков: О проблеме переименования Свердловской области (17.12.2017)

Считаю необходимым высказать некоторые соображения насчет проблемы, затронутой в недавно опубликованной на нашем сайте статье  «ВРНС И РПЦ ЗАКРЫВАЮТ ТЕМУ ВОЗМОЖНОГО ПЕРЕИМЕНОВАНИЯ СВЕРДЛОВСКОЙ ОБЛАСТИ». Хочу обратить внимание на то, что наше общество должно наконец-то определиться с проблемой переименований.
 В основе напряжений, периодически возникающих в том или ином регионе при попытках освобождения от советских наименований и возвращения исторических, лежит наша драматическая история. Общество должно достичь консенсуса по этой проблеме и закрепить его законодательно.  Автор заметки только хочет предложить одно из направлений поиска решения.

 Необходимо договориться о принципах достижения единомыслия по проблеме переименования:

1) Необходимо уважительно относиться к собственной истории: если современники перестали уважительно относиться к историческим деятелям предшествующего исторического периода, то это не означает, что последующие поколения будут поддерживать их точку зрения; современники обязаны уважительно относиться к предыдущим периодам своей истории.

2) Современники не имеют права переименовывать сложившиеся до них исторические названия; это ограничение, накладываемое на современников, даёт им право вернуть исторически сложившиеся названия, если их предшественниками было нарушено право народа на сохранение исторически сложившихся названий; так, совершенно справедливо городу Калинину было возвращено его историческое имя; аналогично Свердловская область может быть переименована в Екатеринбургскую.

3) Современники не имеют права переименовать советские названия городов, улиц, метро и т.д., если они эти названия присвоены объектам, построенным в Советское время.

4) Топонимические преобразования могут приветствоваться в отношении германизмов: «бурги» могут быть заменены на «грады». Так более корректным названием Санкт-Петербурга было бы название «Петроград», которое он и носил после февраля 1917 г.

5) Следование этим принципам будет закреплять реальную историю в названиях городов, улиц и т.д. и внесет в общество понимание, что история такова, какой она была, и от того, переименует современник названия или нет, эта история не изменится; а вот искажение её восприятия современниками может произойти, что будет создавать условия для повторения ошибок прошлого в настоящем и будущем народа.

6) В правилах всегда могут быть исключения: например, Волгоград. Ему может быть возвращено его новое имя «Сталинград», данное в Советский период и ставшее символом героизма советского народа при его обороне. При этом должно учитываться его предшествующее историческое название. Название «Царицын» исторически  нейтрально. Тольятти должен всегда оставаться с этим названием, так как город полностью построен в Советское время, название отражает увлечённость наших отцов и дедов идеями интернационализма; Киров должен опять стать Вяткой, а Кировск Мурманской области должен остаться Кировском; Мурманск должен остаться Мурманском, так как первое его название Романов-на-Мурмане дано ему в год основания только в 1916 году, когда города ещё не было; Краснодар может стать опять Екатеринодаром и т.д. 
17.12.2017

Буренков Александр
Директор Института русско-славянских исследований им. Н.Я. Данилевского, главный редактор газеты "Гражданин-созидатель", предприниматель





Обсуждение статьи



Ваше имя:
Ваша почта:
Комментарий:
Введите символы: *
captcha
Обновить

Вверх
Полная версия сайта
Мобильная версия сайта
Array
(
    [0] => Array
        (
            [REQUEST_2] => 0.066508
        )

    [1] => Array
        (
            [REQUEST_3] => 0.040459
        )

    [2] => Array
        (
            [REQUEST_4] => 0.037175
        )

    [3] => Array
        (
            [REQUEST_5] => 0.036072
        )

    [4] => Array
        (
            [SYSBLOCK_5] => 0.183789
        )

    [5] => Array
        (
            [SYSBLOCK_7] => 0.00036199999999997
        )

    [6] => Array
        (
            [REQUEST_2] => 0.071394
        )

    [7] => Array
        (
            [REQUEST_3] => 0.038577
        )

    [8] => Array
        (
            [REQUEST_4] => 0.032506
        )

    [9] => Array
        (
            [REQUEST_5] => 0.025338
        )

    [10] => Array
        (
            [SYSBLOCK_5] => 0.178589
        )

    [11] => Array
        (
            [SYSBLOCK_7] => 0.00022
        )

    [12] => Array
        (
            [SYSBLOCK_3] => 0.00021199999999999
        )

    [13] => Array
        (
            [SYSBLOCK_4] => 0.00021599999999999
        )

    [14] => Array
        (
            [REQUEST_22] => 0.008366
        )

    [15] => Array
        (
            [REQUEST_39] => -0.526344
        )

    [16] => Array
        (
            [REQUEST_39] => 0.281842
        )

    [17] => Array
        (
            [NAVIGATION_1] => 0.006089
        )

)
Queries
Array
(
    [0] => 
	SELECT * FROM ave_settings_lang
	WHERE lang_status='1'
	ORDER BY lang_default ASC

    [1] => SELECT * FROM ave_settings
    [2] => 
			SELECT
				doc.*,
				rubric_permission,
				rubric_template,
				rubric_meta_gen,
				template_text
			FROM
				ave_documents AS doc
			JOIN
				ave_rubrics AS rub
					ON rub.Id = doc.rubric_id
			JOIN
				ave_templates AS tpl
					ON tpl.Id = rubric_template_id
			JOIN
				ave_rubric_permissions AS prm
					ON doc.rubric_id = prm.rubric_id
			WHERE
				user_group_id = '2'
			AND
				document_alias = 'articles/o-probleme-pereimenovaniya'
			LIMIT 1
		
    [3] => 
						SELECT compiled
							FROM ave_rubric_template_cache
						WHERE hash  = '5a5318bf6c131235070bdab7b6904206'
							LIMIT 1
					
    [4] => 
				SELECT rubric_start_code
				FROM ave_rubrics
				WHERE Id = '3'
				LIMIT 1
				
    [5] => 
							SELECT rubric_header_template
								FROM ave_rubrics
							WHERE Id = '3'
								LIMIT 1
						
    [6] => 
		SELECT *
		FROM ave_request
		WHERE Id = '2'
	
    [7] => 
		SELECT DISTINCT(condition_field_id) AS fid
		FROM ave_request_conditions
		WHERE request_id = '2' AND condition_status = '1'
	
    [8] => SET max_heap_table_size = 1024 * 1024 * 64;
    [9] => SET tmp_table_size = 1024 * 1024 * 32;
    [10] => 		# req=2
		SELECT STRAIGHT_JOIN
			a.*
			
			
		FROM
			ave_document_fields AS t8,			ave_documents AS a
			
			
		WHERE
			(
		a.Id != '1' AND a.Id != '2' AND
		a.rubric_id = '3' AND
		a.document_deleted != '1') AND (a.document_status = '1') AND (a.Id != '33130') AND (a.document_published <= UNIX_TIMESTAMP() AND (a.document_expire = 0 OR a.document_expire >=UNIX_TIMESTAMP())) AND ((t8.document_id = a.id AND (t8.rubric_field_id = '8' AND UPPER(t8.field_value) = UPPER('3'))) AND 1=1)
			
		#GROUP BY a.Id
		ORDER BY a.document_published DESC
		LIMIT 0,5
	
    [11] => SELECT FOUND_ROWS()
    [12] => 
				SELECT *
				FROM ave_module
				WHERE ModuleStatus = '1'
			
    [13] => 
		SELECT *
		FROM ave_request
		WHERE Id = '3'
	
    [14] => 
		SELECT DISTINCT(condition_field_id) AS fid
		FROM ave_request_conditions
		WHERE request_id = '3' AND condition_status = '1'
	
    [15] => SET max_heap_table_size = 1024 * 1024 * 64;
    [16] => SET tmp_table_size = 1024 * 1024 * 32;
    [17] => 		# req=3
		SELECT STRAIGHT_JOIN
			a.*
			
			
		FROM
			ave_document_fields AS t8,			ave_documents AS a
			
			
		WHERE
			(
		a.Id != '1' AND a.Id != '2' AND
		a.rubric_id = '3' AND
		a.document_deleted != '1') AND (a.document_status = '1') AND (a.Id != '33130') AND (a.document_published <= UNIX_TIMESTAMP() AND (a.document_expire = 0 OR a.document_expire >=UNIX_TIMESTAMP())) AND ((t8.document_id = a.id AND (t8.rubric_field_id = '8' AND UPPER(t8.field_value) = UPPER('4'))) AND 1=1)
			
		#GROUP BY a.Id
		ORDER BY a.document_published DESC
		LIMIT 0,5
	
    [18] => SELECT FOUND_ROWS()
    [19] => 
		SELECT *
		FROM ave_request
		WHERE Id = '4'
	
    [20] => 
		SELECT DISTINCT(condition_field_id) AS fid
		FROM ave_request_conditions
		WHERE request_id = '4' AND condition_status = '1'
	
    [21] => SET max_heap_table_size = 1024 * 1024 * 64;
    [22] => SET tmp_table_size = 1024 * 1024 * 32;
    [23] => 		# req=4
		SELECT STRAIGHT_JOIN
			a.*
			
			
		FROM
			ave_document_fields AS t8,			ave_documents AS a
			
			
		WHERE
			(
		a.Id != '1' AND a.Id != '2' AND
		a.rubric_id = '3' AND
		a.document_deleted != '1') AND (a.document_status = '1') AND (a.Id != '33130') AND (a.document_published <= UNIX_TIMESTAMP() AND (a.document_expire = 0 OR a.document_expire >=UNIX_TIMESTAMP())) AND ((t8.document_id = a.id AND (t8.rubric_field_id = '8' AND UPPER(t8.field_value) = UPPER('6'))) AND 1=1)
			
		#GROUP BY a.Id
		ORDER BY a.document_published DESC
		LIMIT 0,5
	
    [24] => SELECT FOUND_ROWS()
    [25] => 
		SELECT *
		FROM ave_request
		WHERE Id = '5'
	
    [26] => 
		SELECT DISTINCT(condition_field_id) AS fid
		FROM ave_request_conditions
		WHERE request_id = '5' AND condition_status = '1'
	
    [27] => SET max_heap_table_size = 1024 * 1024 * 64;
    [28] => SET tmp_table_size = 1024 * 1024 * 32;
    [29] => 		# req=5
		SELECT STRAIGHT_JOIN
			a.*
			
			
		FROM
			ave_document_fields AS t8,			ave_documents AS a
			
			
		WHERE
			(
		a.Id != '1' AND a.Id != '2' AND
		a.rubric_id = '3' AND
		a.document_deleted != '1') AND (a.document_status = '1') AND (a.Id != '33130') AND (a.document_published <= UNIX_TIMESTAMP() AND (a.document_expire = 0 OR a.document_expire >=UNIX_TIMESTAMP())) AND ((t8.document_id = a.id AND (t8.rubric_field_id = '8' AND UPPER(t8.field_value) = UPPER('7'))) AND 1=1)
			
		#GROUP BY a.Id
		ORDER BY a.document_published DESC
		LIMIT 0,5
	
    [30] => SELECT FOUND_ROWS()
    [31] => 
		SELECT *
		FROM ave_request
		WHERE Id = '2'
	
    [32] => 
		SELECT DISTINCT(condition_field_id) AS fid
		FROM ave_request_conditions
		WHERE request_id = '2' AND condition_status = '1'
	
    [33] => SET max_heap_table_size = 1024 * 1024 * 64;
    [34] => SET tmp_table_size = 1024 * 1024 * 32;
    [35] => 		# req=2
		SELECT STRAIGHT_JOIN
			a.*
			
			
		FROM
			ave_document_fields AS t8,			ave_documents AS a
			
			
		WHERE
			(
		a.Id != '1' AND a.Id != '2' AND
		a.rubric_id = '3' AND
		a.document_deleted != '1') AND (a.document_status = '1') AND (a.Id != '33130') AND (a.document_published <= UNIX_TIMESTAMP() AND (a.document_expire = 0 OR a.document_expire >=UNIX_TIMESTAMP())) AND ((t8.document_id = a.id AND (t8.rubric_field_id = '8' AND UPPER(t8.field_value) = UPPER('3'))) AND 1=1)
			
		#GROUP BY a.Id
		ORDER BY a.document_published DESC
		LIMIT 0,5
	
    [36] => SELECT FOUND_ROWS()
    [37] => 
		SELECT *
		FROM ave_request
		WHERE Id = '3'
	
    [38] => 
		SELECT DISTINCT(condition_field_id) AS fid
		FROM ave_request_conditions
		WHERE request_id = '3' AND condition_status = '1'
	
    [39] => SET max_heap_table_size = 1024 * 1024 * 64;
    [40] => SET tmp_table_size = 1024 * 1024 * 32;
    [41] => 		# req=3
		SELECT STRAIGHT_JOIN
			a.*
			
			
		FROM
			ave_document_fields AS t8,			ave_documents AS a
			
			
		WHERE
			(
		a.Id != '1' AND a.Id != '2' AND
		a.rubric_id = '3' AND
		a.document_deleted != '1') AND (a.document_status = '1') AND (a.Id != '33130') AND (a.document_published <= UNIX_TIMESTAMP() AND (a.document_expire = 0 OR a.document_expire >=UNIX_TIMESTAMP())) AND ((t8.document_id = a.id AND (t8.rubric_field_id = '8' AND UPPER(t8.field_value) = UPPER('4'))) AND 1=1)
			
		#GROUP BY a.Id
		ORDER BY a.document_published DESC
		LIMIT 0,5
	
    [42] => SELECT FOUND_ROWS()
    [43] => 
		SELECT *
		FROM ave_request
		WHERE Id = '4'
	
    [44] => 
		SELECT DISTINCT(condition_field_id) AS fid
		FROM ave_request_conditions
		WHERE request_id = '4' AND condition_status = '1'
	
    [45] => SET max_heap_table_size = 1024 * 1024 * 64;
    [46] => SET tmp_table_size = 1024 * 1024 * 32;
    [47] => 		# req=4
		SELECT STRAIGHT_JOIN
			a.*
			
			
		FROM
			ave_document_fields AS t8,			ave_documents AS a
			
			
		WHERE
			(
		a.Id != '1' AND a.Id != '2' AND
		a.rubric_id = '3' AND
		a.document_deleted != '1') AND (a.document_status = '1') AND (a.Id != '33130') AND (a.document_published <= UNIX_TIMESTAMP() AND (a.document_expire = 0 OR a.document_expire >=UNIX_TIMESTAMP())) AND ((t8.document_id = a.id AND (t8.rubric_field_id = '8' AND UPPER(t8.field_value) = UPPER('6'))) AND 1=1)
			
		#GROUP BY a.Id
		ORDER BY a.document_published DESC
		LIMIT 0,5
	
    [48] => SELECT FOUND_ROWS()
    [49] => 
		SELECT *
		FROM ave_request
		WHERE Id = '5'
	
    [50] => 
		SELECT DISTINCT(condition_field_id) AS fid
		FROM ave_request_conditions
		WHERE request_id = '5' AND condition_status = '1'
	
    [51] => SET max_heap_table_size = 1024 * 1024 * 64;
    [52] => SET tmp_table_size = 1024 * 1024 * 32;
    [53] => 		# req=5
		SELECT STRAIGHT_JOIN
			a.*
			
			
		FROM
			ave_document_fields AS t8,			ave_documents AS a
			
			
		WHERE
			(
		a.Id != '1' AND a.Id != '2' AND
		a.rubric_id = '3' AND
		a.document_deleted != '1') AND (a.document_status = '1') AND (a.Id != '33130') AND (a.document_published <= UNIX_TIMESTAMP() AND (a.document_expire = 0 OR a.document_expire >=UNIX_TIMESTAMP())) AND ((t8.document_id = a.id AND (t8.rubric_field_id = '8' AND UPPER(t8.field_value) = UPPER('7'))) AND 1=1)
			
		#GROUP BY a.Id
		ORDER BY a.document_published DESC
		LIMIT 0,5
	
    [54] => SELECT FOUND_ROWS()
    [55] => 
		SELECT *
		FROM ave_request
		WHERE Id = '22'
	
    [56] => 
		SELECT DISTINCT(condition_field_id) AS fid
		FROM ave_request_conditions
		WHERE request_id = '22' AND condition_status = '1'
	
    [57] => SET max_heap_table_size = 1024 * 1024 * 64;
    [58] => SET tmp_table_size = 1024 * 1024 * 32;
    [59] => 		# req=22
		SELECT STRAIGHT_JOIN
			a.*
			
			
		FROM
			ave_document_fields AS t95,			ave_documents AS a
			
			
		WHERE
			(
		a.Id != '1' AND a.Id != '2' AND
		a.rubric_id = '10' AND
		a.document_deleted != '1') AND (a.document_status = '1') AND (a.document_published <= UNIX_TIMESTAMP() AND (a.document_expire = 0 OR a.document_expire >=UNIX_TIMESTAMP())) AND ((t95.document_id = a.id AND (t95.rubric_field_id = '95' AND UPPER(t95.field_value) = UPPER('1'))) AND 1=1)
			
		#GROUP BY a.Id
		ORDER BY a.document_title ASC
		
	
    [60] => SELECT FOUND_ROWS()
    [61] => 
		SELECT *
		FROM ave_request
		WHERE Id = '39'
	
    [62] => 
		SELECT DISTINCT(condition_field_id) AS fid
		FROM ave_request_conditions
		WHERE request_id = '39' AND condition_status = '1'
	
    [63] => SET max_heap_table_size = 1024 * 1024 * 64;
    [64] => SET tmp_table_size = 1024 * 1024 * 32;
    [65] => 		# req=39
		SELECT STRAIGHT_JOIN
			a.*
			
			
		FROM
			ave_document_fields AS t47, ave_document_fields AS t97,			ave_documents AS a
			
			
		WHERE
			(
		a.Id != '1' AND a.Id != '2' AND
		a.rubric_id = '9' AND
		a.document_deleted != '1') AND (a.document_status = '1') AND (a.document_published <= UNIX_TIMESTAMP() AND (a.document_expire = 0 OR a.document_expire >=UNIX_TIMESTAMP())) AND ((t47.document_id = a.id AND (t47.rubric_field_id = '47' AND UPPER(t47.field_value) != UPPER('1'))) AND (t97.document_id = a.id AND (t97.rubric_field_id = '97' AND UPPER(t97.field_value) != UPPER('1'))) AND 1=1)
			
		#GROUP BY a.Id
		ORDER BY a.document_published DESC
		LIMIT 0,30
	
    [66] => SELECT FOUND_ROWS()
    [67] => 
		SELECT *
		FROM ave_request
		WHERE Id = '39'
	
    [68] => 
		SELECT DISTINCT(condition_field_id) AS fid
		FROM ave_request_conditions
		WHERE request_id = '39' AND condition_status = '1'
	
    [69] => SET max_heap_table_size = 1024 * 1024 * 64;
    [70] => SET tmp_table_size = 1024 * 1024 * 32;
    [71] => 		# req=39
		SELECT STRAIGHT_JOIN
			a.*
			
			
		FROM
			ave_document_fields AS t47, ave_document_fields AS t97,			ave_documents AS a
			
			
		WHERE
			(
		a.Id != '1' AND a.Id != '2' AND
		a.rubric_id = '9' AND
		a.document_deleted != '1') AND (a.document_status = '1') AND (a.document_published <= UNIX_TIMESTAMP() AND (a.document_expire = 0 OR a.document_expire >=UNIX_TIMESTAMP())) AND ((t47.document_id = a.id AND (t47.rubric_field_id = '47' AND UPPER(t47.field_value) != UPPER('1'))) AND (t97.document_id = a.id AND (t97.rubric_field_id = '97' AND UPPER(t97.field_value) != UPPER('1'))) AND 1=1)
			
		#GROUP BY a.Id
		ORDER BY a.document_published DESC
		LIMIT 0,30
	
    [72] => SELECT FOUND_ROWS()
    [73] => SELECT * FROM ave_navigation
    [74] => 
		SELECT CONCAT_WS(
				';',
				CONCAT_WS(',', nav.Id, nav.parent_id, nav2.parent_id),
				CONCAT_WS(',', nav.navi_item_level),
				nav.Id
			)
		FROM
			ave_navigation_items AS nav
		JOIN
			ave_documents AS doc
		LEFT JOIN
			ave_navigation_items AS nav2 ON nav2.Id = nav.parent_id
		WHERE nav.navi_item_status = 1
			AND nav.navi_id = 1
			AND doc.Id = 33130
			AND (
				nav.navi_item_link = 'index.php?id=33130'
			OR nav.document_alias = 'articles/o-probleme-pereimenovaniya'
			OR nav.document_alias = '/articles/o-probleme-pereimenovaniya'
			OR nav.document_alias = 'articles/o-probleme-pereimenovaniya.html'
			OR nav.document_alias = '/articles/o-probleme-pereimenovaniya.html'
		
				OR nav.Id = doc.document_linked_navi_id
			)
	
    [75] => 
		SELECT *
		FROM ave_navigation_items
		WHERE navi_item_status = '1'
		AND navi_id = '1'
		ORDER BY navi_item_position ASC
	
)

Время генерации: 3,291 сек.
Пиковое значение 4 414Kb
Количество запросов: 76 шт. за 3,129697 сек.
66   1,464033
# req=39
		SELECT STRAIGHT_JOIN
			a.*
			
			
		FROM
			ave_document_fields AS t47, ave_document_fields AS t97,			ave_documents AS a
			
			
		WHERE
			(
		a.Id != '1' AND a.Id != '2' AND
		a.rubric_id = '9' AND
		a.document_deleted != '1') AND (a.document_status = '1') AND (a.document_published <=
 0,000120 starting
 0,000007 checking permissions
 0,000003 checking permissions
 0,000004 checking permissions
 0,000029 Opening tables
 0,000015 System lock
 0,000071 init
 0,000032 optimizing
 0,000606 statistics
 0,000044 preparing
 0,000701 Creating tmp table
 0,000008 executing
 1,444816 Copying to tmp table
 0,014729 Sorting result
 0,000208 Sending data
 0,000009 end
 0,002212 removing tmp table
 0,000019 end
 0,000004 query end
 0,000064 closing tables
 0,000323 freeing items
 0,000006 logging slow query
 0,000008 cleaning up
72   1,275564
# req=39
		SELECT STRAIGHT_JOIN
			a.*
			
			
		FROM
			ave_document_fields AS t47, ave_document_fields AS t97,			ave_documents AS a
			
			
		WHERE
			(
		a.Id != '1' AND a.Id != '2' AND
		a.rubric_id = '9' AND
		a.document_deleted != '1') AND (a.document_status = '1') AND (a.document_published <=
 0,000120 starting
 0,000007 checking permissions
 0,000004 checking permissions
 0,000004 checking permissions
 0,000030 Opening tables
 0,000016 System lock
 0,000074 init
 0,000034 optimizing
 0,000506 statistics
 0,000052 preparing
 0,000487 Creating tmp table
 0,000007 executing
 1,256003 Copying to tmp table
 0,015852 Sorting result
 0,000219 Sending data
 0,000009 end
 0,001974 removing tmp table
 0,000019 end
 0,000005 query end
 0,000060 closing tables
 0,000072 freeing items
 0,000007 logging slow query
 0,000008 cleaning up